Two major experiments have found no evidence for sterile neutrinos – hypothetical particles that could help explain some puzzling observations in particle physics. The KATRIN experiment searched for sterile neutrinos that could be produced during the radioactive decay of tritium; whereas the MicroBooNE experiment looked for the effect of sterile neutrinos on the transformation of muon neutrinos into electron neutrinos.

Neutrinos are low-mass subatomic particles with zero electric charge that interact with matter only via the weak nuclear force and gravity. This makes neutrinos difficult to detect, despite the fact that the particles are produced in copious numbers by the Sun, nuclear reactors and collisions in particle accelerators.

Neutrinos were first proposed in 1930 to explain the apparent missing momentum, spin and energy in the radioactive beta decay of nuclei. The they were first observed in 1956 and by 1975 physicists were confident that three types (flavours) of neutrino existed – electron, muon and tau – along with their respective antiparticles. At the same time, however, it was becoming apparent that something was amiss with the Standard Model description of neutrinos because the observed neutrino flux from sources like the Sun did not tally with theoretical predictions.

Gaping holes

Then in the late 1990s experiments in Canada and Japan revealed that neutrinos of one flavour transform into other flavours as then propagate through space. This quantum phenomenon is called neutrino oscillation and requires that neutrinos have both flavour and mass. Takaaki Kajita and Art McDonald shared the 2015 Nobel Prize for Physics for this discovery – but that is not the end of the story.

One gaping hole in our knowledge is that physicists do not know the neutrino masses – having only measured upper limits for the three flavours. Furthermore, there is some experimental evidence that the current Standard-Model description of neutrino oscillation is not quite right. This includes lower-than-expected neutrino fluxes from some beta-decaying nuclei and some anomalous oscillations in neutrino beams.

One possible explanation for these oscillation anomalies is the existence of a fourth type of neutrino. Because we have yet to detect this particle, the assumption is that it does not interact via the weak interaction – which is why these hypothetical particles are called sterile neutrinos.

Electron energy curve

Now, two very different neutrino experiments have both reported no evidence of sterile neutrinos. One is KATRIN, which is located at the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) in Germany. It has the prime mission of making a very precise measurement of the mass of the electron antineutrino. The idea is to measure the energy spectrum of electrons emitted in the beta decay of tritium and infer an upper limit on the mass of the electron antineutrino from the shape of the curve.

If sterile neutrinos exist, then they could sometimes be emitted in place of electron antineutrinos during beta decay. This would change the electron energy spectrum – but this was not observed at KATRIN.

“In the measurement campaigns underlying this analysis, we recorded over 36 million electrons and compared the measured spectrum with theoretical models. We found no indication of sterile neutrinos,” says Kathrin Valerius of the Institute for Astroparticle Physics at KIT and co-spokesperson of the KATRIN collaboration.

Meanwhile, physicists on the MicroBooNE experiment at Fermilab in the US have looked for evidence for sterile neutrinos in how muon neutrinos oscillate into electron neutrinos. Beams of muon neutrinos are created by firing a proton beam at a solid target. The neutrinos at Fermilab then travel several hundred metres (in part through solid ground) to MicroBooNE’s liquid-argon time projection chamber. This detects electron neutrinos with high spatial and energy resolution, allowing detailed studies of neutrino oscillations.

If sterile neutrinos exist, they would be involved in the oscillation process and would therefore affect the number of electron neutrinos detected by MicroBooNE. Neutrino beams from two different sources were used in the experiments, but no evidence for sterile neutrinos was found.

Together, these two experiments rule out sterile neutrinos as an explanation for some – but not all – previously observed oscillation anomalies. So more work is needed to fully understand neutrino physics. Indeed, current and future neutrino experiments are well placed to discover physics beyond the Standard Model, which could lead to solutions to some of the greatest mysteries of physics.

“Any time you rule out one place where physics beyond the Standard Model could be, that makes you look in other places,” says Justin Evans at the UK’s University of Manchester, who is co-spokesperson for MicroBooNE. “This is a result that is going to really spur a creative push in the neutrino physics community to come up with yet more exciting ways of looking for new physics.”

Both groups report their results in papers in Nature: Katrin paper; MicroBooNE paper.

The post Sterile neutrinos: KATRIN and MicroBooNE come up empty handed appeared first on Physics World.

Gamma rays emitted from the halo of the Milky Way could be produced by hypothetical dark-matter particles. That is the conclusion of an astronomer in Japan who has analysed data from NASA’s Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope. The energy spectrum of the emission is what would be expected from the annihilation of particles called WIMPs. If this can be verified, it would mark the first observation of dark matter via electromagnetic radiation.

Since the 1930s astronomers have known that there is something odd about galaxies, galaxy clusters and larger structures in the universe. The problem is that there is not nearly enough visible matter in these objects to explain their dynamics and structure. A rotating galaxy, for example, should be flinging out its stars because it does not have enough self-gravitation to hold itself together.

Today, the most popular solution to this conundrum is the existence of a hypothetical substance called dark matter. Dark-matter particles would have mass and interact with each other and normal matter via the gravitational force, gluing rotating galaxies together. However, the fact that we have never observed dark matter directly means that the particles must rarely, if ever, interact via the other three forces.

Annihilating WIMPs

The weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) is a dark-matter candidate that interacts via the weak nuclear force (or a similarly weak force). As a result of this interaction, pairs of WIMPs are expected to occasionally annihilate to create high-energy gamma rays and other particles. If this is true, dense areas of the universe such as galaxies should be sources of these gamma rays.

Now, Tomonori Totani of the University of Tokyo has analysed data from the Fermi telescope  and identified an excess of gamma rays emanating from the halo of the Milky Way. What is more, Totani’s analysis suggests that the energy spectrum of the excess radiation (from about 10−100 GeV) is consistent with hypothetical WIMP annihilation processes.

“If this is correct, to the extent of my knowledge, it would mark the first time humanity has ‘seen’ dark matter,” says Totani. “This signifies a major development in astronomy and physics,” he adds.

While Totani is confident of his analysis, his conclusion must be verified independently. Furthermore, work will be needed to rule out conventional astrophysical sources of the excess radiation.

Catherine Heymans, who is Astronomer Royal for Scotland told Physics World, “I think it’s a really nice piece of work, and exactly what should be happening with the Fermi data”.  The research is described in Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics. Heymans describes Totani’s paper as “well written and thorough”.

The post Galactic gamma rays could point to dark matter appeared first on Physics World.