
The Fantastic Four: First Steps dominated the global box office this past weekend, raking in $218 million. It also officially kicked off Phase Six of the MCU - a Phase that will only contain four movies. Yup, two fewer than Phases One and Four, even.
You can check out all the Easter Eggs, name drops, tributes, etc in The Fantastic Four: First Steps here.
With Phase Five now in the rear view, let's rank all of it! Marvel Studios has been struggling some, Post-Endgame. As head Kevin Feige said in his State of the MCU address to Variety, Disney's call for content to fill Disney+ led to, in so many words, too much Marvel. And not only too much to keep track of, but also too many post-credit teases and loose ends that may never pay off. "For the first time ever, quantity trumped quality," Feige stated.
An argument could be made that Phase Five was the weakest of the MCU, with Phase Four thriving a bit more with a marginally higher quality of offerings. Black Widow and Shang-Chi may have gotten cut off at the knees by the pandemic but Phase Four hit ground running with lockdown-ready WandaVision, Loki, Hawkeye, and more on the streaming front. By Phase Five though, the Multiverse Saga officially felt bereft and directionless. Phase Four's Eternals may have been the first MCU film to be classified as "rotten" on Rotten Tomatoes but it was the stumbling of Phase Five opener Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, and its real life Kang crisis, that dealt a bigger blow. Also, having Secret Invasion stink up the joint just a few months later did no one any favors.
That's not to say Phase Five didn't have some marvel-ous content, it just also happened to have the worst thing Marvel Studios has ever made. The one project even Marvel apologists will concede was awful. Much of the rest of Phase Five was, unfortunately, middling at best so now we're stuck with a crowded, messy few years of more misses than hits.
But let's not dwell on the negative too much. Aside from underperforming movies and streaming shows that sat on the shelf too long -- victims of a 2021 where everything under the sun got greenlit -- there were some super-duper standouts. Full steam ahead for Ant-Man, Captain America, Captain Marvel, Bucky, Yelena, Rocket, Loki, and more...
Warning: Spoilers for Phase Five movies and shows follow...
14. Secret Invasion
Just dreadful. It's such a shame that we waited so long for Nick Fury to get the spotlight, one even based on a famous comic arc, and it turned out so terribly. Nothing on paper was bad about this, mind you, but now Secret Invasion stands as the only canon series that Marvel fans would happily ignore. What's that you say? Maria Hill's still alive? Great. What else? Rhodey wasn't a Skrull during Avengers: Infinity War and Endgame? Perfect. What else? G'iah doesn't now have the combined powers of The Avengers, Guardians of the Galaxy, and Captain Marvel making her the most powerful being on Earth? Fantastic! Yup, if there was a Roger Rabbit-style "Dip" that could erase Secret Invasion from existence, we'd happily fill our super-soakers.
Note: Since Secret Invasion, the MCU has introduced two more impossibly-powerful characters in Sentry and Franklin Richards. The difference with them though is that there are clear plans for them in the next Avengers movie (and Sentry comes with a failsafe, of sorts). G'iah absorbing the Harvest felt like Secret Invasion writing checks that the MCU had no intention of cashing.
13. Captain America: Brave New World
It's important to recognize the huge gap in quality between Brave New World and Secret Invasion. Even though this Captain America movie is ranked second-to-last, there's a gulf between these two Phase Five-ers.
Brave New World is just a regular misfire, with some decent elements. Like you'd hope for most of the time for things that miss the mark. The biggest issue with Brave New World is that Sam's major arc and best character moments happened on The Falcon and the Winter Soldier and Brave New World was actually a President Ross story (making it even sadder that William Hurt didn't get to play the role). Ross had the emotional journey here whereas Sam was relegated to just being a guy who went from not wanting to reform the Avengers to a guy who agrees to reform the Avengers. It's also clear from the film itself that Red Hulk was meant to be a a third act surprise, and that the audience was suppose to be guessing at Samuel Sterns' plan (with those having read the comics in a better position to predict correctly). Marketing, however, went all in on Red Hulk. So much so you'd assume he came in the middle of the movie and not during the final 10 minutes.
Reshoots don't mean a movie will be bad. Neither does a script still being written during filming. Good movies come from these conditions all the time. But when a film flops it's easy to look at a messy production like Brave New World (cut storylines, characters, etc) and see why it felt so half-formed.
That being said, it was pretty awesome to get Tim Blake Nelson back as Sterns as he was the original "oh they'll never pay this off" MCU loose end.
12. Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania
Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania kicked off Phase Five and even though it opened huge, it fell massively in its second week - a 70% drop off which was officially the largest second week decline in MCU history. The trailer had everyone hyped, and the idea of Kang being the new Thanos was a hit among fans (especially since he was a time traveler and Loki's first season set him up as a huge multiversal threat). So what went wrong?
It was sort of a combination of things, the main one being that fans went into this movie thinking it would be a much bigger turning point for the Multiverse Saga than it would up being. It didn't need to be an Empire Strikes Back level entry but it needed to do something. Change something. By then end, Kang was defeated (some even scoffed at Ant-Man being the hero to destroy the Conquerer) and we got another empty promise in multiversal mayhem. Phase Four's Loki and Spider-Man: No Way Home opened the idea up wide but then Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness killed the momentum, despite it being a fun movie in its own right. Quantumania squashed the momentum again and everyone was back to wondering what was next. When would this ever get followed up on? Scott Lang's worried he made a big big mistake? That was over two years (and six movies) ago.
Oh, and Quantumania's stab at making M.O.D.O.K. work was also an unfortunate blight. It was a swing. It missed. Valiant effort.
Overall, Quantumania's not as bad as you think it is, but it also didn't move us toward anything meaningful at a time when fans were very hungry for a Multiverse Saga through line.
11. Echo
In Phase Five we're going to be dealing with a handful of "this would never have been greenlit today" projects. These are spinoff shows based on characters who Marvel thought popped when they debuted elsewhere and now sadly got their series unceremonious dumped and swept under the rug. The first (and lowest ranked) on the list is Echo, centered on Native American hearing-impaired crime boss Maya Lopez from the Hawkeye series. As the first series released under the Marvel Spotlight banner -- indicating standalone street-level stories that won't affect broader MCU storylines -- Echo was released all at once. Or maybe dumped is the proper term, given that every previous Disney+ Marvel series was hyped up and rolled out weekly, lasting at least several weeks.
But the streaming waters were different now. The tide had rolled back but Marvel Studios still had shows in the can. Echo wasn't a total loss creatively though, despite what its unceremonious presentation might indicate. Star Alaqua Cox kicked all sorts of butt while both Echo and Hawkeye, as shows, ushered Wilson Fisk back into the MCU. In the end, sadly, Echo was still a middling offering, a character lost in a sea of increasingly banal origin stories and a swarm of streaming series that quickly wear out their welcome because they're designed to feel like overlong movies.
10. Ironheart
Ironheart didn't get the full hatchet job that Echo received, since it was released over two weeks (three episodes at a time), but it still sat around for two years before airing, which made for a long two years since Riri Williams was in Black Panther: Wakanda Forever and five whole years since the project was announced in 2020.
After enduring a round of toxic review bombing, Ironheart, for the most part, was well-received, though always through the lens of "there's too much Marvel and this should have come out a while ago and...holy s***! is that actually Mephisto?" It was an intriguing blend of Stark-style tech and dark sorcery that hadn't been explored before in the MCU, all swirled up with Riri's grief over the death of her best friend and stepfather. It roped in deep cut characters from the world of Iron Man and Doctor Strange but it's medium okay-ness didn't help kick its "also-ran" label. It's a shame Ironheart ended in a cliffhanger since not only will there never be a second season but we may not ever even see Riri again. In fact, the character most likely to emerge from the ashes of Ironheart, in some other MCU project, is Mephisto. Which is funny considering how, for a few weeks, the internet went mad with theories about him behind behind everything in WandaVision.
9. What If...? Seasons 2 & 3
While not technically a part of the MCU, we need to shout What If...? The gorgeously animated anthology series was, like its comic counterpart, hit or miss. Sometimes it floundered with goofy escapades while other times it floored you with interesting subversive concepts and devastating tragedy. It's important to note that this series, like Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man, is canon in a roundabout multiversal way as these are stories actually occurring in other Marvel universes. And the best thing What If...? did was create a serialized element to its seasons that culminated in huge cross-dimensional battles against mega-villains like Infinity Ultron (in Season 1, yes), Strange Supreme, and even the Order of the Watchers.
We're combining both seasons two and three of What If...? for this entry since they both more or less equal quality-wise and together they tell one story, with Captain Carter at the heart of it, leading the Guardians of the Multiverse in a quest to stop threats to reality itself. It was all pretty cool considering that the show's first episode, "What If... Captain Carter Were the First Avenger?", was just a rudimentary flip on Captain America with no big surprises. It had us worried that every episode would just be a replay or run through of an MCU movie with a few things flipped. But What If...? wound up being much more than that, thankfully. It was even the project that brought Sam Rockwell back as Iron Man 2's Justin Hammer ("What If... Happy Hogan Saved Christmas?").
8. Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man
It can't be a surprise that Peter Parker/Spider-Man adventures always makes for a great watch. There's a reason he's been Marvel's top dog for 25 years in theaters (and 70 years in the comics). Peter's seemingly never-ending struggle to balance his life as a genius teen who pines for a specific classmate and his dangerous escapades as a wall-crawling, web-slinging vigilante has basically become a go-to blueprint for superhero stories.
With standout animation and fun tweaks to the Spidey formula (his best friend is Nico Minoru, he goes to school with Tombstone, Harry Osborn is an influencer, etc), Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man fits nicely into the What If...? corner of the Multiverse Saga, giving us new twists and turns while still embracing what people love about the character, at his core. It is, admittedly, a series that works best if you already know Spider-Man's "greatest hits" but by this point most people, or enough people, do.
7. The Marvels
The Marvels got done dirty at the box office. It's better than people give it credit for. Is it a crowning jewel for the MCU? Of course not. But it was an inspired, hilarious team-up that worked as a sequel to both 2019's Captain Marvel and the Ms. Marvel Disney+ series. It's failure, unfortunately, came at a time when "superhero fatigue" was an internet rallying cry and repugnant review bombing was commonplace (note: Captain Marvel and Ms. Marvel were also previously review bombed if you're looking for the obvious misogynist pattern).
The one glaring thing that The Marvels proved though, with its across-the-board financial failure, was that streaming series-to-movie pipeline was busted from the beginning. Thunderbolts* would also run into this brick wall. People were not following characters from TV to the multiplex so that fact that two-thirds of the Marvels came from streaming series was an Achilles heel that somehow wasn't anticipated. Still, box office aside, The Marvels was a funny and heartfelt cosmic caper with an amusing take on body-swapping (location swapping?) and one hell of a surprising use for Flerkens.
6. Deadpool & Wolverine
Deadpool's official raunchy MCU debut was actually more of a 20th Century Fox superhero eulogy, working to close the books on past heroes we'd never see again via the threat of Wade Wilson's "universe" being pruned by the TVA. More importantly though, it was the surefire billion dollar hit Marvel Studios desperately needed after Quantumania biffed it it and The Marvels beefed it.
Deadpool will always get people into the theater. There are moviegoers out there who will see Deadpool movies even if they don't watch all, most, or even some of the MCU. But the winning billion dollar ticket here was Hugh Jackman returning as Wolverine and giving fans a ferocious, emotional performance after years of Jackman and Ryan Reynolds joshing with one another following Reynolds' disastrous Deadpool in 2009's X-Men Origins: Wolverine. It didn't matter that Jackman said he'd never play the role again after Logan. This was all too goofy and exciting to not get hyped and psyched about. And then seeing Jennifer Garner, Wesley Snipes, Dafne Keen, and Chris Evens (as Johnny Storm) all return was delightful icing.
Seeing John Krasinski play Reed Richards in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness was an inspiring nod toward the internet but it was nothing compared to seeing Channing Tatum don the Gambit suit and trench coat, actually fulfilling a once-promised dream.
5. Daredevil: Born Again
Despite Iron Fist's impressive failure which, on some levels, ruining the vibe for the entire Defenders-verse on Netflix, there's still a lot of affinity for those characters and the stars who played them. We didn't know what the ultimate plans were ten years ago but we all just assumed Charlie Cox, Kristen Ritter, Mike Colter, Jon Bernthal, and the rest of the street-level characters from the five Netflix series (and one miniseries) would continue on somehow, in movies or whatnot. But with the demise of Marvel Television as a separate entity and Marvel Studios creating streaming series for Disney+, it all became pretty uncertain (despite Cox's cameo in Spider-Man: No Way Home). But then, little by little, Cox and Vincent D'Onofrio would get invited to the dance (She-Hulk: Attorney at Law, Hawkeye, etc) and hope was back on the menu.
The true shift, however, that gave us the great Daredevil: Born Again (which was massively reworked, re-shot, and retooled in some rather insane ways) was Marvel Studios ditching the idea that everything needed to be connected, which also meant everything needed to be in the same Marvel "tone." Daredevil could once again be edgier and darker and exist as he used to on Netflix. Born Again is tragic, gritty sequel to the original three seasons of Daredevil set in a New York now legally run by Mayor Wilson Fisk. The events of the series, and all that happens in NYC, won't affect anything in the MCU, but now that's okay. We're at a point now where we almost prefer our food not touching. Born Again is free to be brutal, bloody, and bold, as Matt Murdock reels from personal loss and contends with his arch-nemesis now being a beloved public figure (who loves to rip apart freakin' faces, by the way - sheesh!).
4. Agatha All Along
The only holdover show from the Create More Content Era™ that didn't get treated like a shameful secret was Agatha All Along.
This grand, enchanting WandaVision spinoff, from WandaVision writer Jac Schaeffer, was allowed to release weekly, making fans' treacherous march down the Witches' Road a truly spellbinding affair. Agatha All Along was dark, mysterious, and campy in all the right ways. Its magical "elimination round" format made for a unique blend of surprise and suspense that allowed Agatha to be both silly and sinister. It also helped it feel like an actual TV show rather than an elongated movie. And with Kathryn Hahn returning for another twisted turn as Agatha Harkness, it's no wonder this series is one of the best reviewed projects of the last two Phases.
Agatha All Along is the second part of what's meant to be an unofficial trilogy, wrapping up with the upcoming Vision Quest, and with Wanda "dying" in Multiverse of Madness, it was great to get both a spiritual follow up to Scarlet Witch's story and the crafty Billy Maximoff reveal. Wanda "perished" knowing that her kids existed in, apparently, ever other universe but Agatha All Along made one of them whole on Earth-199999.
It also didn't hurt to have Aubrey Plaza playing Death after the character was first teased all the way back in Phase 1. Just sayin'.
3. Loki: Season 2
The fact that fans were still on board with Loki's second season despite Jonathan Majors' involvement and the endless stream of nonsensical TVA technobabble (the entire season is an overloaded version of Star Trek's "teching the tech") is a testament to Tom Hiddleston and the enduring love for the God of Mischief. In Season 2, with the entire multiverse in crisis mode, Loki had to make decisions about his own fate. The backstabbing variant, who once saw the TVA as a new place to rule, a new throne to sit upon, finds "glorious purpose" through self-sacrifice, learning the meaning of love and friendship for the first time in his life.
Loki was the first of the Disney+ MCU series to get an official Season 2. It wasn't as impishly fun as the first season -- with its emotional send-off in the finale remaining the highlight of the uneven stretch of episodes that preceded it -- but it was still a satisfying sequel featuring one of the MCU's greatest legacy characters. Those who skipped it, however, may be very surprised to see what Loki's deal is when he pops up again in Avengers: Doomsday. If that Loki is the Loki from the Loki series. Or if Hiddleston is even playing Loki and not someone else.
2. Thunderbolts*
The most critically-acclaimed movie of Phase Five, Thunderbolts* gave fans the mega-team movie they'd been wanting since Endgame. It just didn't come in the form of the Avengers. At least not the old Avengers, right?
It was a thrilling, moving ensemble that filled the Avengers void, the Guardians void, and the...Void void. It was deep and thoughtful and had unexpectedly emotional messaging about mental illness and the power of community. And it was enough of a creative success that director Jake Schreier is helming the MCU's X-Men movie.
Financially? Well, we're still in a murky period for Marvel Studios where they just can't get the box office return they need for these $200 million dollar movies (which is why, of course, the next three movies are Spider-Man, Avengers, Avengers). Kevin Feige confirmed what everyone found out the hard way with The Marvels, which was that the Disney+ streaming shows were not a strong enough launching pad for movies. By design, this movie was about B (C?) level characters forging their path as misfits, but when you have a team of mid-carders and/or curtain jerkers, you're gonna get the equivalent in dividends at the box office.
Still though, Thunderbolts* is excellent. It continued to solidify Florence Pugh's Yelena as the best new post-Endgame character while also successfully introducing Marvel's warped version of Superman, Sentry - which was the "dark" unstable take on Superman in the comics long before Zack Snyder tried his hand. Thunderbolts* is funny, touching, and more about battling inner demons than cosmic threats.
1. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3
Unlike Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, James Gunn's third and final Guardians movie delivered the tears, turmoil, and resolution that the trailer seem to promise. Yes, before Gunn would leave Marvel (this time of his own accord) to forge and lead the new DCU, he'd make sure we were all bawling our freakin' eyes out.
With a loathsome villain in High Evolutionary, a backstory for Rocket filled with emotional and physical agony, needle drops from the likes of Faith No More and Beastie Boys, incredible laughs, thoughtful resolutions, and the MCU's first official pre-Deadpool & Wolverine F-bomb, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 was a perfect swan song for these beloved heroes. Even though he didn't necessarily want to use Adam Warlock, and resented having had to set him up back in Vol 2., Gunn made it all flawlessly work, writing and directing one his best movies on the way out the door. We'll see many of these characters again but the loss of Gunn will definitely be felt.
Many of the post-Endgame sequels were sad sad stories, from Spider-Man: No Way Home to Thor: Love & Thunder to Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. Guardians Vol. 3 may be the biggest sobfest of them all but it also has a pitch perfect, form fitting ending. It may not be "happy," but it's damn rewarding.
Matt Fowler is a freelance entertainment writer/critic, covering TV news, reviews, interviews and features on IGN for 17 years.